‘Wintergirls’ by Laurie Halse Anderson

★ ★ ★ ☆☆

wintergirls

Photo by Peychaud

Technically there is a lot to love about this book. Original writing style, strong and scary themes, magical realism, relatable characters. It’s great really. Only now I am so hungry. And rather sad. I hate it when books make me feel like this – though I guess that’s when you know it is a good book. I found this book very hard to rate. It was amazing truly. But I wouldn’t read it again. It’s too sad. A little too dark and real for my tastes. It deserves 4 stars – and if I were an impartial robot, I would give it just that – but this is my personal blog space and I can do whatever the hell I like. So that’s why I gave it 3.

Far be it from me to actually give a scholarly review or even give a summary of the book – I’m just not that kind of girl – but I suppose I could give you my version of it.

Lia is a wintergirl. For anyone wondering what the title of the book has to do with anorexia – it doesn’t really. It’s just Laurie’s made up word to describe the girls like Cassie and Lia, girls who are essentially dying of starvation. Lia she sees food in numbers (calories), she loves most of her family, though doesn’t appreciate much they do for her. She doesn’t have a job, or go to school too much, plays no sports, has no friends, and only ever pretends to read books. I can only assume because she doesn’t actually possess the strength to do any of this. It makes me shudder to think of how weak and crumbly she probably is. Laurie does an excellent job of Lia. She is completely real to me. I feel like I went to school with her. It leaves a bad taste in your mouth, it really does. Anyway, plot goes: Cassie dies, Lia is already suffering some serious mental problems and can’t seem to cope with the grief on top of that. She fights her family and pretends she is trying to get better, when really she is doing the opposite. There isn’t really a big climax, just rises and falls throughout the story. I read it in a night.

One problem I foresee for ‘Wintergirls’ is the unbelievable accuracy of the inside look at the mind of a girl suffering from anorexia. I’ll be the last person to blame an author for the way people read into their books – but I was sort of disgusted in the way Lia thinks. I just know some teenage idiot is going to use this book for thinspiration. It makes me annoyed when people use my precious literature to further their own delusions. I feel like the struggle of the family and the helplessness they feel is shadowed by Lia’s own mental state, that unless you recognise that Lia is actually cray, you wont be able to see the effect she is having on everyone around her.

Id cry if I could, I really would.

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “‘Wintergirls’ by Laurie Halse Anderson

  1. Bec Graham

    Books about mental illness can be terrifying in their accuracy. I read a book called Killing Aurora in primary school (year 6 I think) and it’s stayed with me for years. But you are so right about how some people would use this book. There was actually a website that told people how to be anorexic as a life choice. People scare me sometimes…

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
    1. Amy Wallin Post author

      Yes. When I first read the Virgin suicides, I couldn’t get it out of my head for months. It’s strange how nothing is really glamourised yet people are still attracted to it. I think I need to read something cutesy and sweet now….

      Like

      Reply
      1. Bec Graham

        I like that there’s no reason given for the suicides in the Virgin Suicides. Suicide is so conplex that I’m so grateful that Eugenides didn’t try to simplify it.
        Hmm…cutesy and sweet. Some of The Bane Chronicles maybe? 🙂

        Like

        Reply
  2. Pingback: ‘Paper Towns’ by John Green | It's Only Three

  3. Pingback: Lucky I’ve read enough | it's only three

Thanks for commenting! I love to read your opinions (and validations hehe)

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s